| # | Record | Season | Edition | Player | Team | Coach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1t. | 4 | S46 | M19 | Matthew Ioannidis | Washington Redskins | MrWitness36 |
| 1t. | 4 | S06 | M06 | Aaron Kampman | Green Bay Packers | Grantvity |
| 4t. | 3 | S85 | M26 | Greg Rousseau | Buffalo Bills | Bhicks14 |
| 4t. | 3 | S80 | M25 | Tyrann Mathieu | San Francisco 49ers | MMXCalibur |
| 4t. | 3 | S70 | M23 | Jamal Adams | Seattle Seahawks | Pettigrew95 |
| 4t. | 3 | S63 | M22 | Deone Bucannon | Arizona Cardinals | Commish Jeff |
| 4t. | 3 | S62 | M22 | Tyson Campbell | Carolina Panthers | SonGoku |
| 4t. | 3 | S60 | M21 | Jamal Adams | Seattle Seahawks | Mindenplaya |
| 4t. | 3 | S56 | M20 | Jamal Adams | New York Jets | Pettigrew95 |
| # | Record | Season | Edition | Player | Team | Coach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2. | 13 | S51 | M20 | Keanu Neal | Atlanta Falcons | BigReg |
| 3. | 12 | S24 | M13 | LaRon Landry | New York Jets | Latinyank77478 |
| 4t. | 11 | S55 | M20 | Landon Collins | Washington Redskins | Portisss26 |
| 4t. | 11 | S55 | M20 | Derwin James | Los Angeles Chargers | Texmexgalvan |
| 6t. | 10 | S53 | M20 | Bobby Wagner | Seattle Seahawks | Hovadagod_23 |
| 6t. | 10 | S53 | M20 | Derwin James | Los Angeles Chargers | Texmexgalvan |
| 6t. | 10 | S52 | M20 | Bobby Wagner | Seattle Seahawks | Hovadagod_23 |
| 6t. | 10 | S51 | M20 | Luke Kuechly | Carolina Panthers | Dpanther95 |
| 6t. | 10 | S23 | M13 | LaRon Landry | New York Jets | Latinyank77478 |
