| # | Record | Season | Edition | Player | Team | Coach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1t. | 187 | S09 | M07 | Robbie Gould | Chicago Bears | Lhu27 |
| 3. | 181 | S74 | M24 | Justin Tucker | Baltimore Ravens | Mack |
| 4. | 178 | S73 | M24 | Wil Lutz | New Orleans Saints | Boobie_MTZ7 |
| 5. | 176 | S85 | M26 | Tyler Edmond | Philadelphia Eagles | Canesbucs1 |
| 6. | 172 | S78 | M25 | Harris Mevis | Green Bay Packers | Mack |
| 7. | 171 | S65 | M22 | Tucker McCann | Cleveland Browns | Canesbucs1 |
| 8. | 170 | S79 | M25 | Brandon Aubrey | Dallas Cowboys | Coach QKP35 |
| 9t. | 168 | S82 | M26 | Matthew Wright | Houston Texans | Boobie_MTZ7 |
| 9t. | 168 | S81 | M25 | Jake Bates | Detroit Lions | Canesbucs1 |
